Please note: This website contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
.
I need to be honest with you: I have a problem, and it’s simmer pots.
What started as tossing orange slices and cinnamon sticks in a pot for company has turned into an unreasonable number of jars — my candles just sit there now, untouched, gathering dust like little wax monuments to simpler times.
Here’s where the obsession actually pays off, though: when people started asking what my house smells like every time they walk in, I realized these jars make one of the best gifts I’ve ever put together. They’re cheap, personal, don’t require knowing someone’s candle preferences (a minefield, honestly), and the recipient gets to make the thing themselves — which somehow makes it feel like a bigger gift than it costs.
Here’s everything I’ve learned about turning a jar of dried fruit and spices into a gift people actually want.
What Makes a Simmer Pot Gift Soooo Good
A simmer pot gift is basically a jar of dried ingredients — fruit, spices, herbs, whatever smells good when it hits hot water — that the recipient dumps into a pot, covers with water, and simmers on low on the stove.
No candle, no wax, no flame near curtains. Just steam carrying the smell through the house for hours, and you can top it off with more water and keep it going for days.
The reason these make such good gifts is that they solve a real problem: most people love the idea of a cozy-smelling home but don’t actually know how to make it happen without buying yet another candle they’ll burn twice.
A simmer pot jar hands them the whole experience — ingredients, instructions, and that little hit of “ooh, I made this” — for less than the cost of a mid-tier candle.
** Don’t miss the bonus at the end where I show you how to make these for about $2 to $3 per gift!
The Base Method (Same Formula, Every Blend)
Once you’ve got this down, you can build a new blend in about five minutes flat.
What you need:
- A mason jar (I use 16oz jars for gifting — big enough to feel generous, small enough to not look like you’re overcompensating)
- Dried fruit slices, whole spices, and/or dried herbs
- A small square of fabric or a jar lid
- Twine or ribbon
- A printable tag with instructions
How to layer it:
- Start with the bulkiest ingredient on the bottom (dried orange or apple slices)
- Add whole spices next (cinnamon sticks, star anise, cloves)
- Top with anything delicate — dried herbs, a few drops of essential oil on a cotton pad tucked at the top
- Seal it up and tie on your tag
Tag wording (steal this, I don’t care!):
Empty jar into a small pot. Cover with water. Simmer on low, uncovered, for as long as you want that “my house smells amazing” energy. Top off with water as it evaporates — one jar will get you 2-3 days of simmering.
That’s it. That’s the whole system. Everything below is just swapping what goes inside the jar.
Vintage Hobnail Design
Mason Jars for Simmer Pot Gifts
Shop on Amazon
$24.99
16 Oz with Lids, 6 Pack
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/15/2026 02:59 am GMT
Five Simmer Pot Gift Jar Blends
| Blend | What to Put Inside | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Classic Yuletide | Cranberries, dried orange slices, 1 cinnamon stick + 3 whole cloves | The full-on Christmas scent. Warm, festive and perfect for anyone who has the tree up before Thanksgiving. |
| Cozy Cabin | Dried apple slices, rosemary, food-safe dried pine + 1 split vanilla bean | Woodsy and cozy rather than traditionally Christmas-y. Think fireplace, flannel and cabin weekend. |
| Citrus & Spice | Dried orange slices, dried lemon slices, 1 cinnamon stick + a few cardamom pods | Bright, warm and versatile. A great choice for winter gifts that don’t need to scream Christmas. |
| Bakery Morning | Dried orange peel, 1 vanilla bean, 1 cinnamon stick + a small handful of whole coffee beans | Cozy and bakery-inspired—like cinnamon rolls and fresh coffee. One of my favorites for chilly mornings. |
| Fresh Start | Dried lemon slices, rosemary + a few juniper berries | Fresh, clean and green without the heavier spices. Especially nice for a housewarming gift. |
Making It Look Giftable, Not Like a Jar of Spices
Here’s the thing nobody tells you: the recipe is only half the gift. A mason jar full of dried orange slices looks like something from my pantry if you hand it over as-is (which, to be fair, it also is). A few minutes of styling is what turns it into something someone wants to put on their counter before they even use it.
- Swap the metal lid for fabric. Cut a circle of cotton, flannel, or burlap a couple inches wider than the jar lid, set it over the top, and secure it with twine or a rubber band hidden under a ribbon. This alone does 80% of the work.
- Tuck something dimensional into the ribbon. A cinnamon stick, a dried orange slice, or a sprig of rosemary slid under the twine knot gives the jar texture and hints at what’s inside before anyone reads the tag.
- Go with kraft paper and twine for a “just picked this up at the farmers market” look, or cream ribbon and gold thread if you want it to look more like something from a boutique.
- Match the ribbon to the blend. Deep red and pine green for Classic Yuletide, cream and sage for Fresh Start, warm orange or rust for Citrus & Spice — it’s a small touch, but it makes each jar look intentional instead of like you grabbed whatever ribbon was closest.
- Tie the tag on last, not first, so it sits on top of the fabric topper instead of getting buried under it.
- Mismatched jar sizes are fine, even good. A little variety across a gift table looks more handmade and less assembly-line.
None of this needs to be Pinterest-perfect — the whole appeal of these is that they look homemade. A little styling just makes sure “homemade” reads as “thoughtful” instead of “unfinished.”
Want to Keep Your Gift Well Under $5?
While the mason jars are cute, they can get a little pricey if you are giving multiple simmer pot gifts. I love the idea of these inexpensive celephane bags and/or the kraft bags with a window. Here are a few examples:
You can easily find these at your local craft store or just order them up on Amazon!
Value Pick
Clear Celophane Gift Bag Bags (100)
Check Pricing on Amazon
$6.49
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/15/2026 02:44 am GMT
Christmas Potpourri Bags Simmer Pot Kraft Paper Bag (50)
Shop on Amazon
$17.99
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/14/2026 09:27 pm GMT
Staying on Budget with Your DIY Gifts
This is rough what I’ve been spending to create these amazing simmer pot gift bags DIY. I go a little overboard with the ribbon, so just watch for sales, especially at Michaels and even the Dollar Store has a few gems on occassion!
| Item | Approx. cost per gift |
|---|---|
| Clear gift bag | $0.10–$0.25 |
| Dried orange/apple slices | $0.50–$1.00 |
| Cinnamon + whole spices | $0.50–$1.00 |
| Cranberries/herbs/greenery | $0.25–$0.50 |
| Ribbon + kraft tag | $0.25–$0.50 |
| Estimated total | $1.60–$3.25 each |
Who to Give These To
This is where the “gift ideas” part comes in, because these jars flex to almost anyone on your list:
- Teachers and coworkers — cheap enough to do in bulk, personal enough that it doesn’t feel like a bulk gift
- Neighbors — the kind of thing you can drop off with a card and not feel like you’re overdoing it
- Hostess gifts — shows up better than a bottle of wine you’re not sure they’ll like
- New homeowners — the Fresh Start blend especially; it’s a “welcome home” without being twee about it
- Anyone who’s impossible to shop for — because let’s be honest, everyone likes their house smelling good, even people who claim to want nothing
Simmer Pot Gift Ideas: FAQs
How long does a simmer pot last?
One jar will usually get you 2-3 days of on-and-off simmering, depending on how much water you’re topping it off with and how low you keep the heat.
Can I reuse the ingredients?
Once, maybe twice, with reduced strength. After that the smell fades and it’s time for a new jar — which, conveniently, is why these make such good repeat gifts.
Is it safe to leave a simmer pot unattended?
No — treat it like anything else on your stovetop. Keep an eye on the water level and never leave it simmering while you leave the house or go to sleep. I like using the crockpot if you aren’t going to be nearby to check on it regularly. You still need to add water occassionally, but it’s a bit more hands off.
Can I make a simmer pot in a crockpot instead of the stove?
Yes, and it’s actually the safer option for longer stretches — set it to low, and you don’t have to babysit a stovetop flame. Just still don’t let it run dry.
Do I need essential oils, or are the dried ingredients enough?
The dried ingredients alone will give you a real, noticeable scent — essential oils just intensify it if you want more punch, especially with pine or fir.
Final Thoughts
I fully recognize that a person who now owns five kinds of dried citrus and a drawer specifically for cinnamon sticks has lost the plot a little. But I’ve made peace with it, because it turns out the thing that made my house smell like a cinnamon roll factory also turned out to be one of the easiest, cheapest, most-loved gifts I’ve ever put together. My candles can keep collecting dust. I’ve got jars to fill.
Please note: This website contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
.
